|
Jamiatul Ulama (Council of Muslim Theologians), Johannesburg |
| Title: | Shabe‑Bara'at [Night of Emancipation] | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Date: | 27 September 2004 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Author: |
Moulana Fazlur Rahman Aazami |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Agency: |
Madrasah Arabiyyah Islamia, Azaadville |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
2. Introduction
3. Some Ahadith concerning Shabe‑Bara'at
5. The special virtues of Shabe‑Bara'at
6. Rasulullâh Sallallâhu ‘alayhi
wasallam Ibadat every night
7. Visiting the graveyard on Shabe‑Bara'at
8. No Specific Salâh for this night
9. Fasting on the 15th. of Sha'bân is NOT
ESTABLISHED from the Ahadith
10.
Fasting during the month of Sha'bân is Sunnah
and ESTABLISHED from the Ahadith
11. The Night of Bara’at and the Qur’ân
12. Some strange and innovated practices associated
with Shabe‑Bara'at
FOREWORD
The Ummah of Nabî Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam is generally
facing a crisis of appalling proportions. The general decline in Dîni knowledge
and awareness is unprecedented in the annals of Islâmic history. Religious
strife and torment is being experienced in every corner of the globe. How far
and distant the days of the glorious regime of the Sahabah seems when the law
of Allâh Ta’âla reigned supreme; and peace, tranquillity and sublimity prevailed.
When one ponders over the situation, a genuine perception is gained of the
great sacrifice and effort required to restore some measure of what has been
lost. An even greater realisation is gained of the fact that the severity of
the situation is such that only the mercy of Allâh Ta’âla, and his acceptance
of our duas could resolve this sad state of affairs. Thus when a wonderful
occasion such as Shabe‑Barât dawns upon us, one realises the tremendous
need for the believers to derive maximum benefit and to turn in unison and beg
and plead from the Most Merciful of All Those Who Show Mercy.
However it must be
understood that Islâm is a pure and unadulterated religion in which no form of
innovation will be tolerated. Only the application of the Holy Qur’ân and it's
supreme and perfect illustration by our beloved Nabî Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam is acceptable in the sight of Allâh
Ta’âla. Any deviation from this is sure to gain naught but loss and
disappointment by it's perpetrators. It was a keen realisation of the
fundamental importance of this authenticity and purity of the teachings of Nabî
Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam to be
protected from adulteration that led to the Sahabah and the chosen scholars of
the first few centuries of Islâm expending untiring efforts towards its
preservation. As the time passed from the demise of Nabî Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam, so too did the efforts of the enemies
of Islâm increase in the quest to vanquish the Dîn of Allâh Ta’âla. One area of
effort was a direct attack at the Muslims and the truth of Islâm.
A second and perhaps
more devious effort was an attack from within. A no‑holds barred attempt
to adulterate and obliterate the true teachings of Nabî Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam so that the name of Islâm remained, but
the practices carried out under its banner would be foreign and contrary to
that revealed to Nabî Sallallâhu ‘alahyi
wasallam. To this end thousands of Ahâdith were fabricated and a
threatening situation developed. However, while such devious plots bore fruit
against the other religions e.g. Christianity (the fabrication of the Trinity,
etc.), Islâm was protected and the sons of Islâm rose to this challenge with
great zest and zeal.
With regard to the
field of Hadith, one cannot possibly go into the various steps and measures
that were taken over the ages in order to protect the authenticity of Hadith
and separate the pure from the fabricated. To mention just a few: Ahâdith were
written down from the time of the Sahâbah
Radiallâhu anhu and transmitted
likewise; Allâh Ta’âla endowed
certain chosen servants with exemplary memories, enabling them to memorise
thousands of narrations with their chain of narrators; an indepth study into
the life and character of every narrator was made— thus enabling the scholars to
establish whether the narrator could be trusted— such studies were recorded and
categorised; great distances were travelled at great expense by the scholars,
in order to establish the authenticity of even the slightest detail, etc. Based on the results of these exhaustive
efforts, Ahâdith were categorised
into various levels of acceptability in the light of the general worth of the
chain of narrators. It will now be the duty of the general Ummah to accept the
rulings of these great scholars in the field of Hadith and to abide by their
opinion with regard to the acceptability of the subject matter of the various Ahâdith. Only in this manner can we hope
to have a clear conscience with regard to our Dîni practices that they truly
stem from the established Sunnah and
are not borne from custom and imitation of other ideologies.
A great tragedy is that
in recent times, when Islâmic knowledge is at such an ebb and when very often
emotionalism becomes weightier than spiritualism, many unaware brothers have
become victims of the enemies of Islâm who are hell‑bent on spoiling the
true teachings of Nabî Sallallâhu ‘alahyi
wasallam. The situation has deteriorated to such an extent that even
certain scholars of Dîn have fallen prey to their devious plans. These adulterated
practices have even begun to be expounded from the Mimbars of our MasâJid. So
great is the problem that some of these practices have become so famous and
accepted that nowadays when some Ulama step forward and in the light of the
opinions of the scholars of Hadith speak out against such practices, people
(sometimes even other scholars) reject these Ulama and turn a deaf ear. Some
feel that there is no necessity for these Ulama to take objection. This is a
grave attitude indeed. We must understand that no matter how beautiful and well‑known
a practice may be, its acceptability is dependant on it being established in
the light of
Moulana Fazlur‑Rahman
Sahib has by means of this and other such booklets made an effort towards
establishing the truth and presenting the true teachings of Nabî Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam before us.
It will now be our duty to appreciate Moulana's efforts by implementing the
true Sunnat practices and abandoning any innovations that may have crept into
our lives, no matter how popular they are or how pure and religious we consider
them to be. It is hoped by means of this treatise that such a view would he
adopted, especially with regard to the occasion of Shabe‑Bara'at. Let us
reiterate the genuine need for us to exert ourselves in Ibâdat and Du’â on this occasion and the importance
of keeping our religious exertions in conformance to the Sunnat and to veer
clear from that which is not established in the light of authentic Ahâdith.
Only then will our efforts bear fruit.
Another important point
is that due to this particular field being a technical and complex one and the
knowledge of the general masses very scant with regard to its terminology, some
of the subject matter of this booklet may prove difficult to understand for
many. An attempt has been made to alleviate this difficulty by means of
detailed footnotes wherever necessary. However, one should make a genuine
attempt to read it with concentration and appreciate its contents. An appeal is
made to the Ulama, if possible, to choose appropriate occasions and read out
the contents of this and other such booklets, illustrating and explaining
wherever necessary. May Allâh Ta'âla accept Moulana's efforts and take much
more work from Him. May He also grant us the tawfîq to accept and practise.
(Translator)
INTRODUCTION
Allâh Ta’âla has, due
to his infinite grace and mercy, presented to His bondsmen some special
occasions wherein they have a golden opportunity of earning the mercy and
forgiveness of Allâh. Some explicit examples of these special occasions are the
month of Ramadân and Laylatul Qadr.
In the same mould is the fifteenth night of Sha'bân. Several Ahâdith extol the
tremendous merit of this occasion. Amongst thern is the fact that countless
people are forgiven by Allâh during this blessed night. It is due to this
reason that this night is called "The night of Bara'at [i.e. the night
wherein judgement of saviour from Jahannam
and punishment is passed].
However, it should be
borne in mind that a vast majority of the narrations declaring the benefit and
virtue of this night are in fact quite weak[1].
The weakness of most of the narrations regarding the virtue of Laylatul Bara'at
is known to many. However, since these narrations are quite numerous and the
weakness in many is not severe, the virtue of this night will be considered
authentic due to the sheer number of these narrations. This is the general
consensus of the scholars of this field. A study of this book will reveal this
quite clearly.
Many fabricated and baseless
ideas regarding Laylatul Bara'at have found place in certain books and have
been blindly accepted by the masses. The aim of this book is to clearly
elucidate in the light of strong evidence, the acceptable and authentic from
the baseless.
The foundation of the Sharî‘ah is the Qur’ân, Sunnah
and lives of the Sahâbah Radiallâhu anhum. Whatever is proven
from these sources should be implemented, and that which is not proven from the
above should be abandoned. The research of the scholars of Tafsîr and Hadîth is
present. Benefit should be derived from these works and in turn conveyed to the
masses as well. It is for this reason that this book is being published. May
Allâh Ta'âla make it a means of
benefit and a saviour for all Muslims. Âmîn.
Moulana Fazlur Rahman Aazami
SOME AHÂDITH CONCERNING SHABE BARA’AT
NOTE 1:
The Muhaddith, Ibnu‑Dihya,
has also agreed that neither has anything authentic been narrated regarding the
fifteenth night of Sha'bân nor has any specific Salât been narrated for this
night via reliable narrators. ‑ Faydhul‑Qadeer
‑ Sharhul Jâmius‑Sagheer Page
317 v2
An overview of the
various narrations regarding this night lends credence to the acceptability of
the virtue of this night. The reason being that although these narrations are
weak, they are numerous and narrated by a number of Sahabah. Some are such that
not much criticism has been levelled at their Sanad (chain of narrators). Ibnu‑Hibbân
has included some of these narrations in his Sahih and Hafiz Mundhiri has remarked regarding the Sanad of some that ‘La Ba'sa Bihi’ (it
is acceptable). Therefore, according to the principal of the Muhadditheen, the
excellence of the Night of Bara’at is proven from a conjunction of all these
narrations. (Check Footnote 1) This
is the general consensus of the Muhaddithîn and Fuqahâ, and this is correct.
Even Allamah Ibnu‑Taymiyyah,
a scholar well-known for refuting such things, also accepts the virtue of the Night
of Bara’at. He says: “So many Ahâdith and reports exist regarding the
excellence of the fifteenth night of Sha'bân that one is compelled to accept
that this night does possess some virtue.” Some of the pious predecessors used
to specially devote this night for Salâh.
‑ Faydhul Qadeer Page 317 v7
Moulana Abdur Rahman Mubarakpuri
writes in his commentary of Tirmidhi: “The sheer number of Ahâdith regarding
this night serves as proof against those people who refute the excellence of
this night.” Tuhfatul‑Ahwazi Page
53 v2
We should therefore not
fall prey to the deception of a few zealots, who completely reject this night.
We should instead derive maximum benefit from this night.
MAY ALLÂH TA’ÂLA GRANT
NOTE 2:
UNFORTUNATE PEOPLE
It is understood from
the Ahâdith that even on this night, some servants of Allâh are deprived of His
forgiveness. They are as follows:
1.
Idolators
2.
Those who harbour enmity against others
3.
Consumers of alcohol
4.
Those who disobey their parents
5.
Those who wear their trousers, kurtas, lungis, etc. below their ankles;
6.
Those who commit adultery and murderers, and
7.
Those who sever family ties.
We can thus gauge the
severity of these sins and the need to perpetually abstain from them as they
are so grave that even on an occasion when Allâh’s mercy comes to the fore,
they still pose an obstacle to our forgiveness.
Every Muslim should
consider carefully and if he is involved in any of these sins, he should
sincerely repent and seek forgiveness for his sins lest he be deprived of this
night. Another important point is the fact that those sins which deal with the
rights of our fellow men [HuqûquI Ibâd], will not be forgiven by Allâh until
forgiveness has not been sought from the one who has been harmed and a genuine
effort to redress the wrong committed against him has not been made.
Oh Allâh, forgive us and the rest of the believers,
the living amongst us and the deceased.
THE SPECIAL VIRTUE OF THE NIGHT OF BARA’AT
The special virtues of
the Night of Bara’at are:
1.
Contrary to other nights wherein the last third of the night has special
blessings and Allâh descends to the lowest Heaven during this section of the night,
on the night of BarWat the special rain of the mercy and forgiveness of Allâh
begins to shower down right from the beginning of the night and continues right
up tin dawn.
2.
The sins of countless of people are pardoned. As already mentioned,
Allâh's deseension during this night to the nearest Heaven occurs from the very
beginning, unlike the other nights. Furthermore, the number of pronouncements
seeking out those who want forgiveness far supereede those which occur on other
nights. (This is the opinion of Rafiz
Zaynud‑Dîn Iraqi ‑ Faydhul Qadeer, Page 317 v2)
It should be remembered
that while all the narrations regarding the Night of Bara’at are weak, the
narrations regarding Allâh’s descending to the nearest Heaven during the last
third of every night are totally correct.[12]
It should therefore be understood in this manner, that Allâh has bestowed upon
his grateful servants a chance to earn His mercy and forgiveness every night.
How unfortunate are we that we fail to capitalise on this wonderful opportunity
that frequents us every night. We are very sinful, and this is our attitude
whereas Rasulullâh Sallallâhu ‘alahyi
wasallam, who was sinless, used to get up during the nights and perform
Salât of lengthy qirât, rukus and sajdahs. The Ummah should never forget this
Sunnat of Rasulullâh. Sallallâhu ‘alahyi
wasallam. Consider the following Ahâdith.
RASULULLÂH'S SALLALLÂHU
‘ALAHYI WASALLAM IBADAT EVERY NIGHT
Hadrat Abû
Hurairah Radiallâhu anhu reports that
Rasulullâh Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam
said: “Almighty Allâh descends to the nearest Heaven during the last third of
every night. He then proclaims: ‘Is there anyone who will make du’â unto me so that I may accept his du’â? Is there anyone who will ask of Me
so that I may grant him? Is there any who desires forgiveness so that I may
forgive him?’” ‑ Bukhari Page 153;
Muslim Page 258 VI.
The narration of Muslim
contains this addition: "He thereafter spreads out his hands and says:
"Who will grant a loan to a being who is neither in need of it nor is he
an oppressor." ‑ Mishkât Page
109.
Amar bin Absah reports
that Rasulullâh Sallallâhu ‘alahyi
wasallam said:
"Allâh is nearest
to His bondsmen during the last ‑portion of the night. If you have the
ability, then make dhikr [remembrance
of Allâh] during this time." ‑
Tirmidhi has quoted this Hadith and remarked that it is Wzisan Sahih
Ghareeb" ‑ Mishkât Page 109.
Hadrat Aisha Radiallâhu anha reports that Rasulullâh Sallallâhu 'alahyi wasallam used to go
to bed during the first portion of the night and he would stay awake the last
portion of the night (i.e. he used to spend this portion of the night in 'ibâdat) ‑ Bukhari and Muslim, Mishkât Page 109.
Hadrat Aisha Radiallâhu anha says that in Ramadân as
well as in other months Rasulullâh Sallallâhu
‘alahyi wasallam would never perform more than eleven raka'ats of Salâh
(i.e. referring to his Tahajjud and Witr). He would first perform four
raka'ats, the sheer magnificence and length of these raka'ats is beyond words.
He would then perform another four raka'ats of resplendent beauty and length
(i.e. the raka'ats were both excellent and long). He would thereafter read
three raka’ats (of Witr). ‑ Bukhari
Page 154 VI
Hadrat Aisha
Radiallâhu anha says that Rasulullâh Sallallâhu
‘alahyi wasallam used to perform such lengthy Salât that his feet would
swell. Sometimes she would say that his feet would crack. When it would be
asked of him: "Why do you strain yourself so much whereas your past and
future errors have been forgiven?", he would reply: "Should I not be
a grateful servant?" ‑ Bukhari
Page 716 V2, Page 152 V]. The recitation of the du’â mentioned in Hadith number 5 is also proven for Tahajjud
Salâh. ‑Muslim Page 192 VI
Hadrat Umar Radiallâhu anhu used to wake up his
wives as well during the last portion of the night so that they also may
perform Salât. He would then recite the verse: “And command your family
members. regarding Salâh and you also remain steadfast thereon. We seek not
sustenance from you but in fact We sustain you and provide for you. Verily the
favourable outcome awaits the pious.” (Sûrah
20 Verse 132)
There are many similar
authentic narrations from which it is understood that Rasulullâh Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam was
extremely particular regarding the performance of Salâh during the nights. He
would vehemently command the companions to do likewise. They also were very
particular with regard to Tahajjud Salât. In fact, the Qur’ân also attests to
this.
Let us reiterate that
while it is indeed commendable that the many weak Ahâdith narrated regarding the
excellence of the Night of Bara’at creates an urge within us to exert ourselves
in Ibâdat on this night, we should realise that the abovementioned strong
Ahâdith should definitely engender within us an even greater urge to do
likewise every night. Consider especially the fact that Allâh descends to the
lowest Heaven during the last portion of every night. Rasulullâh Sallallâhu 'alahyi wasallam and the
Sahabah Radiallâhu anhu were very
particular regarding this and encouragement towards it is present in the Qur’ân
and Hadith. Nevertheless, we must understand that no Ibâdat should be carried out as a customary practice or in
prescribed formulas that have no basis in Sharî‘ah.
VISITING THE GRAVEYARD ON THE NIGHT OF BARA’AT
Rasulullâh's Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam awakening
during the night and visiting the graveyard is recorded in some of the
previously mentioned Ahâdith. However, visiting of the graveyard is not a
special characteristic of this night. Instead, it is proven from another
authentic narration that Rasulullâh Sallallâhu
‘alahyi wasallam would visit the graveyard during the last portion of every
night.
Hadrat Aisha Radiallâhu anha narrates that whenever
it was her turn for Rasulullâh Sallallâhu
'alahyi wasallam to spend the night with, he would visit the Baqî [graveyard
of Madina] and would say:
(Arabic Du’â) [Peace be
upon you, O dwellers of the Muslim graveyard! Death, which was promised to you
has indeed befallen you. You are already journeying towards tomorrow (the
Hereafter). Verily, if Allâh wills, we will also join you. O Allâh, forgive the
inmates of Baqî.] Sahih Muslim.Page 313 VI
Imâm Nawawi writes
"From this it is learnt that visiting the graveyard, greeting its inmates
and making du’â of forgiveness and
mercy for them is Mustahab [desirable].” (Sahih
Muslim Page 313 VI)
There is another Hadith
in the Sahih of Muslim wherein Hadrat Aisha Radiallâhu anha explains a similar subject matter as was seen in
the narration concerning the Night of Bara’at. (It is a generally accepted fact
that all the Ahâdith in Muslim Sharîf are authentic.) She says: "Rasulullâh
Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam once
entered my room when it was my turn for him to spend the night with. He placed
his sheet aside, removed his sandals and kept them at his feet. He spread the
edge of his lungi over the bedding and lay down. He lay still until he thought I
had fallen asleep. He then took his sheet slowly, wore his shoes and gently
opened the door, and (as he left), closed the door very gently. I also dressed,
donned my veil and left behind him. He went to Baqî where he remained standing
for a long time. He thereafter raised and dropped his hands thrice and
returned. I also returned. He was walking fast and I did the same in order not
to be detected. I hastened my pace in conformance to his and thus reached home
before him. Just as I lay down, he entered the room. He asked: ‘O Aisha, why
are you breathing so heavily?’ I replied that there was nothing to it. He said:
‘Tell me otherwise Allâh will inform me.’ I replied: ‘May my parents be
sacrificed for thee and then related the entire incident to him. He asked: Are
you the same person I saw in the distance? I replied in the affirmative. He
gave me a slight push with his fist in my chest, the effect of which I felt,
and he asked once again: ‘Did you think that Allâh and His Rasûl Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam would
oppress you?’ I replied: ‘No matter how much people try to hide something from
you, then too Allâh informs you.’ Rasulullâh Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam then said to me Jibra’îl Alayhis Salâm came to me. He secretly
called me. I also secretly answered him (this concealment was due to the fact
that) he does not enter the room when you have removed your clothes. I thought
that you had fallen asleep and did not desire to awaken you. Besides, I feared
that you would become scared. Jibra’îl Alayhis
salâm said to me: Your Lord commands you to visit the inmates of Baqî and
make du’â for their forgiveness. Hadrat
Aisha Radiallâhu anha questioned Rasulullâh
Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam as to
what he recited there. He replied: Say (the following
(Arabic Du’â) [Peace be
upon the believing [Mu'min] inhabitants of the home and may Allâh shower mercy
upon the deceased amongst us and those whose death still awaits them. And
verily, if Allâh wills, we will soon join you.] (Sahih
Muslim Page 314 VI)
There is no specific
reference to this Hadith to the Night of Bara’at or any other night.
Furthermore, it is understood from the previous Hadith that whenever it was Hadrat
Aisha's Radiallâhu anhu turn for Rasulullâh
Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam to spend
the night with, he would visit the graveyard. Thus, a wide and general
application of this practice is understood. Aside from visiting the graveyard
on the Night of Bara’at, we should ponder as to what extent our practice
conforms to the authentic Ahâdith of Nabî Sallallâhu
‘alahyi wasallam. Are we following a norm, or are our actions truly spurred
by an intention to follow the Sunnah? The turn of Hadrat Aisha Radiallâhu anha occurred once every
week. It can thus be concluded from the above riwâyat that Nabî Sallallâhu
‘alahyi wasallam would visit the graveyard a minimum of once a week.
Hadrat Buraidah
Aslami Radiallâhu anhu narrates that Rasulullâh
Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam said:
"I originally
prohibited you from visiting the graves, however I now advise you to visit the
graves." Another Hadith on the topic adds that this will cause you to
remember death. ‑ Sahih Muslim Page
314 VI.
This Hadith does not
restrict the visit to either day or night. We should therefore visit the
graveyard whenever we have an opportunity. Remember death and make du’â for the forgiveness of the
deceased. We should not suffice with visiting the graveyard on the Night of
Bara’at and thereafter neglect this virtuous act during the rest of the year.
In the Hadith, no specific day e.g. Friday, Thursday, etc., has been reserved
for the visiting of the graves. We should therefore abstain from giving any
particular day significance for this practice.
THERE IS NO SPECIFIC PRESCRIBED SALÂH RESERVED FOR THE NIGHT OF BARA’AT
Allamah Anwar Shah
Kashmin (R) has written regardmg the matter that the significance of the Night
of Bara’at is proven. There is however no proof for those weak and unacceptable
narrations mentioned in certain books. ‑ Alarfus‑Shazi Page 156.
Allamah Yusuf Binnouri Rahimahullâh writes in Ma'arifus‑Sunan that Abû Talib
Makki recorded these narrations in his book Qutul‑Quloob.
Imâm Ghazali, following Abû Talib Makki, did the same and Shaikh Abdul Qadir
Jilani has followed them in his book Ghunyat‑ut‑Talibîn.
They mention a narration of Hadrat Alî Radiallâhu anhu that discusses a Salâh of one hundred raka'ats. However, Ibnu‑Jawzi Rahimahullâh and others declared this
narration to be a fabrication [Mawdhu']
‑ Page 419 V5. Allamah Dhahabi,
Ibnu‑Arraq, Suyuti, Mulla Ali Qari and other scholars of Hadith have
vehemently refuted such Namâzes. (Those who desire further references should
consult the books of Mowdhu'ât [fabrications].)
N.B. lmam Dhahabi says
regarding the book Ghunya‑tut‑Talibîn
that although it is the work of Shaikh Abdul Qadir Jilani, many additions were
made to his book after his death. -Taqrîr
Moulana Shabeer Ahmad Uthmani, published by Jamea Islâmeah Dhabel Page 277.
The above book therefore cannot be relied upon. As far as Hadith is concerned,
the opinion of the scholars of Hadith [Muhaddithîn]
is always considered and not that of Wâ’izîn and Sufis.[13]
Mulla Ali Qari has
discussed this matter under a special chapter regarding the prescribed Namâzes of
the Night of Bara’at. After mentioning these Namâzes, he declares them to be
unfounded and therefore writes that these Namâzes were first introduced in the
fourth century in Baitul‑Muqaddas and thereafter Ahâdith were fabricated
in order to support these baseless formulae. ‑ Mowdhuâti‑Kabeer
Page 330 Beirut edition, also see Tadhkiratul‑Mowdhu’ât of Fattni Page 45
FASTING ON THE FIFTEENTH
OF SHA'BÂN IS NOT ESTABLISHED FROM HADITH
Some people are of the
misconception that fisting on the fifteenth of Sha'bân is Sunnat. They have
been deceived by the Hadith of Hadrat Alî Radiallâhu anhu that appears in Ibnu‑Majah. This narration is
totally unreliable. An interesting point is that fasting on this day is only
discussed in this weak Hadith. No other narration regarding any significance of
fasting on this day is found. This Hadith is Hadith number 8 that passed. It
was also mentioned in the footnote under the hadith that one of its narrators,
Ibnu‑Abi‑Sabirah, is a very weak narrator and has been accused of
fabricating Hadith. ‑ Mizanul‑I’itidal
of Dhahabi Page 503 v4. No action can be proven as Sunnat on the basis of
such a weak Hadith.
The author of Durre‑Mukhtar
writes that the condition (pre‑requisite) for practising upon a weak
Hadith is that:
Allamah Shami explains
in the commentary of this excerpt that an example of severe weakness would be
when at least one of the narrators of the hadith is a liar or accused of
fabricating Hadith. (This factor is found in this Hadith as already explained.)
He thereafter quotes from Imâm Suyuti that at no time of practising on such a
Hadith should it be regarded as proven. (Ibid)
This Hadith is extremely weak and it is not even narrated by any other chain of
narrators.[14]
Fasting on this day
therefore cannot be regarded as Sunnat, it could be regarded as Nafl only. If
fasting on this day be regarded as Sunnat, this will result in attributing to Rasulullâh
Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam something
which cannot be proven from him and this could be very dangerous. Nabî Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam said: “Abstain
from reporting (attributing) Hadith from me except concerning that (Hadith)
which you have knowledge of (are certain of its authenticity). He who
attributes a lie to me should prepare his abode in Hell.”
Baihaqi has quoted a
narration in Shua'bul‑lmân which discusses a Namâz of fourteen raka'ats,
after which Sûrah Fateha, Sûrah Ikhlâs, Sûrah Falâq, Sûrah Nâs, Ayâtul Kursi,
etc. should be read fourteen lines each. The following day (fifteenth of
Sha'bân) should be spent in fasting. The reward of fasting on this day being
equivalent to two years of fasting. Baihaqi thereafter quotes Imâm Ahmad's
statement that this Hadith seems to be a fabrication and it is ‘Munkar’ [unacceptable].
Amongst its narrators
is Uthmân bin Saced and others who are unknown. Shua’bui‑Imân of Baihaqi
Page 387 V3.[15]
Shaikh Abdul Haq Muhaddith
Dehlawi, after quoting this Hadith, quotes similar remarks regarding it and
thereafter writes that Jawzani has regarded this Hadith as baseless and Ibnu‑Jowzi
has regarded it as a fabrication and says that the chain of narrators of this
Hadith is obscure. Ma-Thabata‑bis‑Sunnah
Page 213.
FASTING DURING THE MONTH OF SHA'BÂN IS SUNNAT AND A
CLEARLY ESTABLISHED PRACTICE OF SHARΑAH
Fasting in the month of
Sha'bân, without the stipulation of any day, is proven from Rasulullâh Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam. In fact, he
used to fast excessively during this month.
Hadrat Aisha Radiallahu anhu describing the fast of
Nabî Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam says
that aside from the month of Ramadân, he never used to fast for the entire month.
However, of the remaining eleven months, he would fast in Sha‘bân the most. –
Bukhari, Page 264 VI. Although it is mentioned in some narrations that Rasulullâh
Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam would
fast throughout the entire month of Sha'bân, however the famous scholar of
Hadith, Abdullah bin Mubarak, explains that these Ahâdith refer to fasting the
major portion of the month. General Arabic usage permits a person to refer to
the majority of the month spent in fasting as being the entire month. ‑ Tirmidhi Page 155
Ibnu‑Abbas Radiallâhu anhu has also narrated that
besides the month of Ramadân, Rasulullâh Sallallahu
‘alayhi wasallam never spent the entire portion of any month in fasting. To
fast excessively during the month of Sha'bân would therefore definitely be in
conformance to the Sunnat of Rasulullâh Sallallâhu
‘alahyi wasallam.
However, one should not
fast during the second half of Sha'bân if one fears that one might become weak,
thus putting off the fast of Ramadân. Hadrat Abû Hurairah Radiallâhu anhu narrates that Rasulullâh
Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam has said:
“Do not fast during the second half of Sha'bân.” Tirmidhi, Page 155. Imâm Tahawi has interpreted the prohibition in
the above Hadith to be based on compassion and sympathy. He writes that the
person who fears weakness (due to excessive fasting in Sha'bân) will be well
advised not to fast during the second half of Sha'bân so that he may be able to
keep the compulsory fast of Ramadân without any strain. ‑ SharhuMa'anil‑Âthâr Page 289 VI
Similarly, it will not
be correct to fast during the last one or two days of Sha'bân, if such a fast
is kept with the intention that should Ramadân have already started, (and no
one saw the moon) then I will not be missing any of its fasts. Rasulullâh Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam had
prohibited this.[16]
Yes, if it is a
person's habit to fast at the end of every month or during a specific day of
the week. and that day occurs at the end of Sha'bân, then such a person will be
permitted to fast during the last days of Sha'bân since such a fast would not
be kept on account of Ramadân.
Similarly, the general
masses would not be permitted to fast on the day of ‘Shak’ [doubt]. They should instead wait until
NOTE: The day of Shak
refers to the 30th of Sha’bân when, due to overcast conditions on the night
preceding it, one is placed in doubt over the sighting of the moon.
THE NIGHT OF BARA’ÂT AND THE QUR’ÂN
Has the Night of
Bara’at been mentioned in the Qur’ân? The most correct opinion is that the Night
of Bara’at has not been mentioned in the Qur’ân.
Allâh Ta‘âla says in Sûrah Dukhan:
"By the oath of the clear Book (the Holy Qur’ân). Verily We revealed it
(Holy Qur’ân) in a blessed night. Verily We are the Warners. On this night die
decision of every matter of wisdom is passed and established." (Verses 2‑5).
The words "blessed
night" in the above verse refers to Laylatul
Qadr which occurs in the last ten days of Ramadân. Laylatul Qadr has been called "A Blessed Night” because
unlimited Divine blessings descend upon the creation on this night. As
mentioned in Sûrah Qadr, the Qur’ân was revealed in this night. Similarly, it
is mentioned in Sûrah Baqarah (Verse 23) that the Qur’ân was revealed from the Lawhe‑Mahfuz [a protected tablet
in the Heaven] to the lowest Heaven, in the month of Ramadân.
The meaning of the
above‑mentioned verse from Sûrah Dukhan would therefore mean that
on the night of "Qadr" the details of all those who will die or
receive sustenance, etc., during the forthcoming year are transmitted from the
Lawhe-Mahfuz to the Angels. (Ibn‑Kathîr). This is the opinion of most
commentators of the Qur’ân such as Ibnu‑Abbas, Qatadah, Mujahid, Hasan
Basri, etc. Scholars such as Imâm Nawawi have also accepted the authenticity of
this opinion. Hafiz Ibn‑Kathîr writes that those like Ikramah who have
explained the "Blessed Night" in the above verse as the Night of
Bara’at are very distant from the correct interpretation. The reason being that
the âyat refers to the night of the revelation of the Holy Qur’ân, which has
already been proven to be Laylatul Qadr. (Ibn-Kathîr in the Tafsîr of Sûrah Dukhan,
Ma’arifus‑Sunan, Page 420 V5),
Ma’ariful Qur’ân Page 757 V7. Ibn‑Kathîr writes further that there is a
Hadîth attributed to Uthmân ibn Muhammad that Rasulullâh Sallallâhu ‘alahyi wasallam said: "The ages of people (i.e.
whether they live further) are decided from Sha'bân to Sha'bân. A person
marries and is even blessed with a child, yet his name is amongst those who are
to die (and he is completely unaware)."
This Hadith is however Mursal and cannot be given credit when
its subject matter directly contradicts that which has been established from
the Qur’ân. (i.e. that these decisions are passed to the Angels on Laylatul Qadr and not on the Night of Bara’at). Qazi Abû Bakr bin
Arabi writes that there is no reliable Hadith regarding the fifteenth of
Sha'bân from which it may be understood that sustenance, life and death are
decided on this night. He has even gone so far as to say that there isn't any
reliable narration concerning this night being a blessed one. – Ma’riful- Qur’ân
Page 757 V7. Since the significance of the Night of Bara’at has been mentioned
in a number of weak narrations, and the narrations are not in conflict with any
verse of the Qur’ân or any authentic narration, we do accept its significance.
However, the opinion that sustenance, death, etc. are determined on this night
is in conflict with the Qur’ân and is therefore unacceptable. It is on this
account that the research scholars have always rejected this opinion. The
opinion of the lecturers would not be considered in this discussion, instead
the opinion of the scholars of Tafsîr
and Hadîth would be considered.
A Hadith that is
attributed to Ibmi‑Abbas Radiallâhu
anhu states that sustenance, life and death are decided on the Night of Bara’at
and this information is transmitted to the Angels on the Night of Qadr. (Ruhul‑Ma’ani).
However, this Hadith is unreliable since its chain of narrators are unknown.
There is a Hadîth of Hadrat
Aisha Radiallâhu anha mentioned in
Mishkât (Page 115) on the authority of Baihaqi's Da’wâtul‑Kabîr. This Hadîth discusses that decisions are
passed on this night regarding those that will be born, those that will die,
the actions of man are placed in front of Allâh and sustenance is revealed. The
condition of this Hadith is unknown and it is possible that the scholars of
Tafsîr and Hadîth do not consider it reliable.
SOME STRANGE AND
INNOVATIVE PRACTICES ASSOCIATED WITH SHABE‑BARA’AT
The occasion of Shabe‑Bara'at
has become synonymous with some baseless beliefs and practices to mention just
a few:
1. Burning Bright
Lights and Lanterns:
Shah Abdul Haqq
Muhaddith Dehlawi [Rahimahullâh] writes
that an evil bid'ah that takes place
quite commonly in
Nabî Sallallahu ‘alayhi wasallam said:
"He who imitates a nation is from amongst them. (Abû Dawûd, p.215)
It is thus necessary
that Muslims completely abstain from such practices. Expending money in this
direction would be Harâm and should
children be given money for purchasing firecrackers then the parents will be
answerable for this.
Shah Sahib, after
throwing some light on the history of this practice writes further that the ‘Ulamâ have slammed the practice of
burning extra lights on specific nights as an evil bid'at indeed.
Ali bin Ebrahim has
said that the Barâmika, a sect belonging to the Majûs [Fire-worshippers] were
in fact responsible for the initiation of this Bid'ah. Upon accepting Islâm they began practising such things
considenng them as Sunnat. The object
was that together with making sajdah
with the Muslims they would also be worshipping fire. Then some Imâms and
leaders used this innovation in order to gather people in large numbers under
the pretext of special namazes, etc. Having gathered a crowd they would then
attempt to establish their leadership and control over the people. At the
beginning of the 8th century Hijri the ‘Ulamâ‑e‑Haqq
began denouncing this strange practice and it was thus abolished from
It is indeed a tragedy
when one considers the fact that a study of the Ahadith that have passed
earlier on in the book reveal quite clearly that Rasulullâh Sallallahu ‘alayhi wasallâm didn't even have a
single lantern in his home on the Night of Bara’at. Yet his Ummah and those who
profess love for him, consider the act of burning lights on this occasion to be
one of great virtue and merit.
2. Preparing of Sweet
Meats: Some people consider this as being compulsory. Without it there can be no ShabeBara'at for them. This is also absolutely baseless. Some say that this act gains significance from the fact that on the occasion of Uhud. when the blessed tooth of Rasul Sallallahu ‘alayhi wasallâm became Shahîd, he had some halwa. Others say that Hadrat Hamza Radiallâhu anhu was matyred on this day and the sweetmeats are taken as his ‘Fâtiha’ [tribute]. These are fabricated and concocted theories. How can it ever be possible when it is known fact that the battle of Uhud in which Hadrat Hamza was martyred took place in Shawwâl and not Sha'bân
3. Souls Visit Families
Some people firmly
believe that on Shabe‑Bara'at
the souls of the deceased visit the families' homes and see whether any food
has been prepared in their honour or not. Some feel that if a person dies
before Shabe‑Bara'at and until
his ‘Fatihah’ is not made on Shabe‑Bara'at,
he is not counted amongst the dead. These are baseless ideologies that clearly
contradict the Ahâdith.
4. Distribution of Food
Some feel that it is
compulsory to distribute food on this night with the intention of Isale‑Thawâb. There is no link between this practice and the
significance of this night. Any virtuous act could be carried out without
considering it as specific to this night. This custom should also be avoided.
One could easily feed on any other day or night for that matter. Furthermore,
no other special acts of charity etc. have been prescribed for this night. (Fatâwâ Imdadiyyah Vol. 41,Page27).
5. Hadith on Rajab,
Sha'bân and Ramadan
Some people quote the
following narration in their lectures: Rasulullâh Sallallahu ‘alayhi wasallâm
said: "Rajab is Allâh's month, Sha'bân is my month and Ramadân is the
month of my Ummah." It should be noted that this ‘Hadith’ is a fabrication.
(Akhbâr –Mowdhû’ P. 329)
O Allâh! show us that
which is Haqq [Truth] and cause us to
follow it and show us that which is Bâtil
[False] and cause us to abstain from it. May Allâh shower his choisest
blessings upon the best of His creation, Hadrat Muhammad Sallallahu ‘alayhi wasallâm
and upon his
Companions, his descendants and upon his entire Ummah. Âmîn. All praise
is due to Allâh in the beginning and in the end.
Fazlur‑Rahman A'azami 26 Jumâdal‑Ukhra 1413‑21 December 1992
[1]
It should be noted that the veracity of this statement can only be truly
appreciated by one familiar with the science governing the principles of Hadith
(Usûl‑e‑Hadith). Let us suffice to say that what is meant is that
there are certain deficiencies present in one or more of the narrators of some
Ahâdith, thus reducing the reliability of these narrations with regards to
their authenticity. These deficiencies vary in their natures and severity, thus
governing the classification of the particular Hadith (i.e. each chain of
narrators has to be studied individually before its classification). While in
one instance the deficiency may be that one of the narrators is known to have a
weak memory, another case may have the problem that one narrator is a famous
liar and fabricator of Hadith. It is quite apparent that the degree of harm in
both cases differs. The crux of the matter is that, Alhaindolillah, Allâh
Ta'ala has endowed certain individuals with exemplary abilities in this field and
they have expended tremendous efforts in the classification of Ahâdidi with
regards to their strengths. We should accept their rulings and abide by its
application. One such principle should be noted; In the case where there exists
several narrations concerning a particular virtue or benefit despite most of
them being weak, the virtue or benefit will still be accepted due to the
conjunction of the narrations (i.e. the sheer number of narrations, despite
their weakness, lend credence to the authenticity of their subject matter,
Translator).
[2]
As is well-known, in the
Islâmic Calender, the night precedes the day. Hence the night between the
fourteenth and fifteenth of Sha'bân is implied.
[3]
Mursal is such a narration
wherein a Tâbie [a Muslim who was not
blessed with the sight of Nabî Sallallâhu
‘alahyi wasallam, but lived during the age of the Sahabah] narrates a
statement or action of Rasulullâh Sallallâhu
‘alahyi wasallam i.e. he does not mention which Sahabah he heard it ftom.
Thus
it becomes clear that a gap exists in the chain of narrators. Such a narration
in the opinion of Imâm Abû Hanifla and Imâm
Malik
(R) is acceptable. This acceptability will obviously refer to those cases where
the Tâbi'e concerned is of such high merit that one would expect only good from
him. Imain Shâfl and Imâm Ahmad (R) also accept the Mursal when it is supported
by another narration. This is exactly the case here.
[4]
This type of
Mursal is also referred to as 'Munqati'
i.e. a gap; exists in the chain of narrators. In this case it means that Makhûl
did not hear this Hadith from Abû Tha’labah
Radiallâhu
anhu. directly but from someone else who 'in turn heard it from Abû
Tha’labah Radiallâhu anhu. The name
of this person is unknown.
[5]
Targhîb wat Tarhîb is a
kitâb consisting of a collection of Ahâdith compiled by Hâfiz Munziri. In his
introduction, Hâfiz Munziri clearly stated that any riwâyat in his compilation
having the following two attributes are weak anf unreliable: (1) usage of the
word ‘ruwiya’ in the beginning, and (2) he does not comment at the end of the
Hadith ‑ Introduction Targhîb wat Tarhîb Page 37. This Hadith fits the
above description and is thus a weak narration. It is recorded in Durre‑Manthur
that Bailiaqi also regarded this Hadith as weak ‑ Durre Manthur Page 27
Volume 6.
[6]
It is obvious that a
physical descension is not implied, since Allâh Ta’âla is omnipresent. In this
case and others wherein physical attributes are given to Allâh Ta’âla, we refer
to these as "Mutashâbihât." The human mind cannot fully comprehend
what is truly meant by this, nor are we required to comprehend it. Our duty is
to believe firmly in the truth of its occurrence and to consider that a
descension in keeping with the greatness and majesty of Allâh does indeed
occur. However, the manner of its occurrence is unknown to us.
[7]
This riwâyat is weak because
one of the narrators, HajâJ ibn Artât, is a weak narrator. (He has been branded
by the scholars of Hadith as unreliable). Besides he did not hear this Hadith
from Yahya ibn Abi Katheer. The narration is therefore Munqati. Imain Bukhari
says that Yahya ibn Abi Katheer also did not hear this Hadith from Urwa bin
Zubair. Thus there exists two gaps in the chain of narrators. ‑ Tirmidhi
[8]
One of the narrators is Ibmi‑Lahiyah,
who has been declared as weak and unreliable. ‑ Tuhfatul‑Ahwadhi
Page 53 V2. The gradient for acceptance of riwâyât applied by Dahâk (another of
the narrators of this Hadith) is unknown. Furthermore, he did not hear Ahâdith
from Abû Musa Ash'ari Radiallâhu anhu.
Faidhul‑Qadeer Page 263 v2 [9] One of the narrators in the chain of narrators of this Hadith is Ibnu‑Abi‑Jabrah. There is a difference of opinion regarding his actual name. He has been accused of fabricating Hadith. ‑ Taqrib of Ibnul‑HaJr Page 396. Imâm Ahmad said that he fabricates Hadith. Nasa'i said that his narrations should be abstained from. Ibn Ween said that his narrations are baseless. Imâm. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||